Wide Gap Brazing when Parts don’t Fit Together well for Brazing
A common occurrence (unfortunately) in the brazing world is the need to join two parts together by brazing in which the brazing gap is too large, i.e., in the range of 0.010-inches (0.25 mm) or larger. Ideal brazing clearances should be in the area of 0.000-inches to 0.005-inches (0.00mm to 0.125mm) maximum for most brazing filler metals (BFMs).
Brazing depends on capillary action to draw the liquid BFM into the brazing joint, and tight clearances are needed for best brazing to occur. If the BFM is pre-placed in the brazing joint prior to assembly of the parts then capillary action is not a major factor since the BFM will melt in-situ and join the two members without the need for flowing any distance through tight capillary spaces. But, when the BFM is applied externally, or if a preform ring of BFM is placed in a groove internally, and the BFM must melt and flow through the joint by capillary action, then clearance become a critically important factor.
Too many brazing shops have to send parts through their brazing operations twice, three-times, or more, because the brazing gap (clearance) does not properly fill during the brazing run, and additional brazing runs must be made, with additional BFM each time, in order to finally be able to fill the large gap that exists between parts. This can lead to weak joints, or grossly distorted parts, excessive grain growth, etc.
If a large gap exists, and it must be brazed, then it is quite possible to braze it successfully using a “wide-gap brazing” process. The steps to follow to do it successfully in only one brazing run are:
1. Be sure the gap is very clean (free from oils, grease, dirt, and oxides). If necessary, submit the parts for state-of-the-art fluoride-ion cleaning prior to brazing the assembly (this is commonly done for parts coming back for repair from extensive aero-engine service).
2. As shown in the drawing on the right (courtesy of Practical Welding Today Magazine, May/June 2000 issue, from an article I wrote for them at that time), pack base-metal powder into the wide-gap between the parts. It is important to match the powder with the base-metal. Thus, if brazing 304-stainless parts, use 304 S/S powder to fill the gap. Bear in mind that this base-metal powder is not intended to be melted. It is a gap-filler, and should not be melted. The powder size (mesh) should be such that it can be easily placed into the gap, leaving spaces between the powder particles for brazing filler metal (BFM) to flow. Packing density of the base-metal powder will be assumed to be approximately 50-percent.
3. Apply the desired BFM powder or paste on the outside of the joint, equal to about 60-percent of the volume of the gap, since about 50-percent of the joint will be taken up by the base-metal powder, and the 10-percent extra BFM applied will be needed to compensate for any variations in gap clearance, and also to provide a slight meniscus (filleting) on the outside of the joint.
4. Braze the assembly, causing the BFM to melt, and flow by capillary action between the base-metal powder particles in the joint, joining them firmly in place, and allowing the gap to be successfully brazed in one attempt only.
When done properly, large gaps can be brazed successfully this way, with a high degree of strength and integrity. Many companies have learned to do this successfully over the years, but many more companies need to learn this technique.
If you are uncertain about how to perform this operation in your plant operations, please let me know, and I’ll be happy to guide you.
Dan Kay – Tel: (860) 651-5595 – Dan Kay operates his own brazing consulting/training company, and has been involved full-time in brazing for 40-years. Dan regularly consults in areas of vacuum and atmosphere brazing, as well as in torch (flame) and induction brazing. His brazing seminars, held a number of times each year help people learn how to apply the fundamentals of brazing to improve their productivity and lower their costs. Dan can be reached via e-mail at dan (at) kaybrazing.com, and his website can be visited at: http://www.kaybrazing.com/ To View a listing of all Dan’s articles please click here Read Dan Kay’s Biography © Copyright Dan Kay 2010